Collins, S. & Lawford-Smith, H. (2016). The transfer of duties: From individuals to states and back again. M. Brady, M. Fricker. The epistemic life of groups: Essays in the epistemology of collectives 150-172. United States of America: Oxford University Press. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198759645.003.0009
We often make claims about the duties of states. One might think, for example, that Australia has a duty to legalize homosexual marriage, or that the United States has a duty to make healthcare affordable. Can such duties be explained in terms of individuals’ duties? This chapter argues that many—though not all—can. The chapter builds a general and abstract analysis of how some collectives’ duties are explained by individuals’ duties, and applies it to states in a way that retains common-sense intuitions about states’ duties. It then uses that analysis to suggest a new sense of membership in a state. The analysis depends crucially on epistemic elements, including the beliefs and transfers of information required for reciprocal recognition and intentional participation; certain other bidirectional transfers of knowledge; and the required degree of justification for certain key beliefs.
Dianoia Institute of Philosophy
Access may be restricted.