Never-married Women versus the records: archives, testimony and the history of adoption practices at the Royal Women's Hospital

Journal article


Quirk, Christin. (2012). Never-married Women versus the records: archives, testimony and the history of adoption practices at the Royal Women's Hospital. Melbourne Historical Journal. 40(1), pp. 169 - 183.
AuthorsQuirk, Christin
Abstract

During the period 1945-75, the demand for adoptable babies for infertile couples in Australia was at its peak, with over forty-five thousand adoptions legalised in Victoria alone. At this time, often referred to as the ‘heyday’ of adoption, up to sixty-eight per cent of never-married mothers were separated from their babies. Adoption was characterised as a mutually advantageous solution that guaranteed the moral and social redemption of mother and child, with adoptive parents cast as benevolent and sympathetic. Within this context, mothers who lost a child to adoption were marginalised, stigmatised, and unable to acknowledge their grief and loss. Amid claims that past closed adoption practices were unethical, and even illegal, oral history was identified as the most appropriate investigative tool for revealing individual understandings, but also for uncovering what were believed to be undocumented practices. However, although this research has been primarily informed by interviews with single mothers and former hospital staff, archival research has provided rich documentary evidence with which to contextualise and corroborate this testimony. Despite representing differing perspectives on the same story, this article will reflect on the complementary nature of these two sources of evidence in writing the history of mothers who lost a child to adoption at the Royal Women’s Hospital (RWH) in Melbourne

KeywordsAdoption; History; Melbourne; Australia
Year2012
JournalMelbourne Historical Journal
Journal citation40 (1), pp. 169 - 183
ISSN0076-6232
Web address (URL)http://journal.mhj.net.au/index.php/mhj/article/view/90
Open accessOpen access
Page range169 - 183
Research GroupSchool of Arts
Publisher's version
Permalink -

https://acuresearchbank.acu.edu.au/item/8qz2w/never-married-women-versus-the-records-archives-testimony-and-the-history-of-adoption-practices-at-the-royal-women-s-hospital

  • 70
    total views
  • 0
    total downloads
  • 4
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month
These values are for the period from 19th October 2020, when this repository was created.

Export as

Related outputs

The business of adoption: past practices at the Royal Women's Hospital, Melbourne
Quirk, Christin. (2013). The business of adoption: past practices at the Royal Women's Hospital, Melbourne. Lilith: A Feminist History Journal.
Past Adoption Practices and the Politics of Apology
Quirk, Christin. (2013). Past Adoption Practices and the Politics of Apology. Australian Policy and History.
Never-married Women versus the records: archives, testimony and the history of adoption practices at the Royal Women's Hospital
Quirk, Christin. (2012). Never-married Women versus the records: archives, testimony and the history of adoption practices at the Royal Women's Hospital. Melbourne Historical Journal. 40(1), pp. 169 - 184.
The other thing was...': The reciprocal interview relationship and the impact of 'unconnected' traumatic memories
Quirk, Christin. (2012). The other thing was...': The reciprocal interview relationship and the impact of 'unconnected' traumatic memories. Oral History Association of Australia Journal. 34, pp. 47 - 53.
Separated at birth: Adoption practices in relation to single women confined at the Royal Women's Hospital 1945-1975
Quirk, Christin Anne. (2012). Separated at birth: Adoption practices in relation to single women confined at the Royal Women's Hospital 1945-1975 [Thesis]. https://doi.org/10.4226/66/5a9626bbc6886